A few weeks ago, I was listening to someone complain that their search engine status had dropped from the first page of Google. While this indeed spells tragedy for most internet marketers, search engine heartbreak is never permanent. The pain of falling out of favor with Google is thankfully, only a temporary and easily remedied thing.
So, this guy was bemoaning the disappearance of his site for his chosen keywords. Trying to be helpful, I went to his homepage and clicked on the source code. There were a few things that I didn't see there, that I should have seen. Some really basic stuff, like the aforementioned keywords, which should have been part of the page title tag, but alas, were not. Basic, yet critical things.
And there were some other picciune items, like an oddball way that he had chosen to name his metatags. Could the misnomer of the tags be a problem? Well... who can say, but the fact is this. If I'm staring at four other sites that are ranking well for your keyword, and you're the only one who's NOT ranking well (in fact not ranking at ALL), and the major difference is that your tags are oddly labeled... well, stop yerr bellyaching, fix the tags to match everyone else's, check back in a week and see what transpires.
I dispensed advice to this nice gentleman, and then I waited, hopeful for him, that things would return to their previously pleasant state over on the Google Search Bar. But then, instead of him taking a chance and making an adjustment to fit the changing times, I saw him a week later. He was bitching to someone else about the same problem. Looked at the source code, saw that he hadn't done a thing with it. I shrugged. Hey, it's not my job to keep after people after I offer them free tips.
That said, here's my theory on Google. Everyone speaks in hushed voices about the dreaded Dupe Content Penalty. Everyone quivering in fear, dreading the day that Google strikes back at them for some unholy website act they didn't know they committed. Or, if they're not cringing beneath the Wrath of Google, they're taking the Rebel stance. "Nyah, nyah, I don't need to know about search engine optimization! I'll just write great content and keep publishing it and you'll see!"
Let's take a sane approach to this issue. Websites have certain functionality features that help search engine spiders find them. If these features are used incorrectly or not used at all, that makes it more difficult for them to be found. If SOME of the pages of a website utilize these features, but others don't, then only PART of the site can be properly categorized. So, all this really is, is you trying to get found. For your keywords. Using the tools that web developers gave you for this very purpose.
The truth is, nobody who works at Google has any CLUE what you and your website are up to. There is no Google Squad of Human cyber cops, waiting to hunt you down, lest you make a wrong move. There's no evil Google nun, eager to whip out her wooden ruler and thwap you on the back of the hand for breaking the Google laws. There's not even a Google meter maid, handing out tickets to websites who have parked but failed to pay the Google dues. And there is most certainly no Google Hell, where Bad Website Owners are cast for all eternity. (But people sure make out like there is one, don't they??)
Google rank is based on an algorithm. It's just math. There's some kind of fancy equation programmed in there, and being math-phobic I shudder to think what that equation might look like. But I know it's there, and all it's doing is making calculations of some kind for "must-haves" that it expects the good website owner to follow.
And, being logical about it, one would think that Google might put a PLUS-SIGN by those aspects of web content that are meant to communicate the keywords and "help" the search engine bots index the content quicker. Things like links. Navigation. Pyramid structure, with the broadest subjectmatter on top and the category heads in links beneath, with the "deep content" being housed on single pages, linked to via headlines, using keywords of course. (This is why everyone wants niche-based articles. Articles are deep content. The more you have, and the better you index it, the higher you go.) Also, things like image alt tags and page titles, and link titles, which I just found out about two months ago by some kind blog commenter (thanks for that tipoff, buddy!).
So, to sum this up in a nutshell. If you've got something screwy about your site, instead of wailing to the high heavens that you're on Google's Poop List, try this. Just fix it. Find out what you have to do, or what you did but shouldn't have, and correct the problem. Because by fixing whatever isn't web-bot-friendly about your site, you make it easier for the web crawlers to come back, find you, scan your site and reindex your content.
And then when you're reindexed, all the boo-boos and wrist slaps are magically erased. And then Patsy Cline will be singing, "I'm back in Google's arms... how I missed those loving arms... I'm back in Google's arms, back where I belong."
God, I am a dork.
Your Google-crazed pal,
Dina at Wordfeeder.com Copywriting and Marketing